Rank the Nominees

[Dr.ciski77]

Picture
1 - The Favourite
2 - BlacKkKlansman
3 - Black Panther
4 - Roma
5 - A Star Is Born
6 - Green Book
7 - Bohemian Rhapsody

n/a: Vice

Director
1 - Pawlikowski
2 - Lanthimos
3 - Lee
3 - Cuaron

n/a: McKay

Actor
1 - Cooper
2 - Mortensen
3 - Malek

n/a: Bale, Dafoe

Actress
1 - Glenn Close
2 - Olivia Colman
3 - Melissa McCarthy
4 - Lady Gaga
5 - Yalitza Aparicio

Supporting Actor
1 - Sam Elliott
2 - Richard E. Grant
3 - Adam Driver
3 - Mahershala Ali

n/a: Rockwell

Supporting Actress:
1 - Weisz
2 - De Tavira
3 - Stone

n/a: Adams, King

[dws1982]

Picture:
1- The Favourite
2- A Star is Born
3- BlacKkKlansman
(the only three I liked)
4- Black Panther
5- Roma
6- Bohemian Rhapsody
7- Green Book
8- Vice

Director:
1- Pawlikowski
2- Lanthimos
3- Lee
4- Cuaron
5- McKay

Actor:
1- Cooper
(the only good performance, in my opinion)
2- Dafoe
3- Malek
4- Bale
5- Mortensen

Actress:
1- McCarthy
2- Colman
Depending on the day, I might swap McCarthy and Colman.
3- Gaga
4- Close
5- Aparicio

Supporting Actor:
1- Grant
2- Driver
3- Elliott
4- Ali
5- Rockwell

Supporting Actress:
1- Stone (but lead)
2- Weisz (but lead)
3- King
4- DeTavira
5- Adams

Original Screenplay:
1- First Reformed
2- The Favourite
(the only two good screenplays, in my opinion)
3- Roma
4- Vice
5- Green Book

Adapted Screenplay:
1- If Beale Street Could Talk
2- Can You Ever Forgive Me?
3- BlacKkKlansman
4- A Star is Born
5- The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
(much stronger than Original Screenplay, in my opinion)

[eurocheese]

Breaking from past years and going with how I'd fill out a ballot instead of my personal preference.

Best Picture
1. Roma
2. The Favourite
3. Black Panther
4. A Star is Born
5. BlacKkKlansmen
6. Green Book - I liked it a lot but have zero desire to see it win BP
7. Bohemian Rhapsody - same, and I'll add it's a guilty pleasure more than a good movie
8. Vice

Director
1. Cuaron
2. Lanthimos
3. Lee
4. Pawlikowski
5. McKay

Actor
1. Cooper, who is honestly getting hosed this season
2. Malek
3. Mortensen
4. Bale
5. Dafoe

Actress
1. Close by a hair
2. Colman
3. Aparicio
4. Gaga
5. McCarthy

Supporting Actor
1. Ali
2. Driver
3. Elliott
4. Grant
5. Rockwell - it was a fun cameo, but this nod is silly

Supporting Actress
1. King - I really want her to win over the competition though she's not in my personal top 5
2. De Tavira
3. Weisz
4. Stone - Doesn't need the win but she's actually my favorite
5. Adams

Original Screenplay
1. The Favourite
2. Green Book - the dialogue was its strong suit, but I hope The Favourite wins
3. Roma
4. Vice
5. First Reformed

Adapted Screenplay
1. If Beale Street Could Talk
2. BlacKkKlansmen
3. Can You Ever Forgive Me?
4. A Star is Born - acting and direction were stronger than script for me
Haven't seen Buster Scruggs and may not bother

[malcolm1980]

I'll rank ALL the Oscar-nominated films I've seen and edit it as I go along.

01. Roma
02. The Favourite
03. Isle of Dogs
04. Shoplifters
05. Spider-Man: Into The Spider-Verse
06. Minding The Gap
07. If Beale Street Could Talk
08. BlacKkKlansman
09. First Reformed
10. Black Panther
11. A Quiet Place
12. One Small Step
13. Bao
14. A Star Is Born
15. Incredibles 2
16. Ralph Breaks The Internet
17. First Man
18. Can You Ever Forgive Me?
19. Lifeboat
20. A Night at the Garden
21. The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
22. Mirai
23. Hale County This Morning, This Evening
24. Mary Poppins Returns
25. Avengers: Infinity War
26. Free Solo
27. Border
28. Weekends
29. The Wife
30. Cold War
31. Late Afternoon
32. Of Fathers and Sons
33. End Game
34. Black Sheep
35. Period. End of Sentence
36. RBG
37. Green Book
38. Christopher Robin
39. Animal Behavior
40. At Eternity's Gate
41. Ready Player One
=================================
42. Vice
43. Solo: A Star Wars Story
44. Bohemian Rhapsody

DIRECTOR
01. Alfonso Cuaron
02. Yorgos Lanthimos
03. Spike Lee
04. Pawel Pawliwkawski
-------------------------------
05. Adam McKay

ACTOR
01. Bradley Cooper
--------------------------------
02. Willem Dafoe
03. Rami Malek
04. Christian Bale
05. Viggo Mortensen

ACTRESS
01. Olivia Colman
02. Glenn Close
03. Melissa McCarthy
04. Yalitza Aparicio
05. Lady Gaga
(strong category though, i actually liked all of them)

SUPPORTING ACTOR
01. Richard E. Grant
02. Adam Driver
03. Sam Elliott
04. Mahershala Ali
-------------------------------
05. Sam Rockwell (wasted nomination)

SUPPORTING ACTRESS
01. Regina King
02. Rachel Weisz
03. Emma Stone
04. Marina de Tavira
---------------------------------
05. Amy Adams

ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY
01. The Favourite
02. First Reformed
03. Roma
--------------------------------
04. Green Book
05. Vice

ADAPTED SCREENPLAY
01. If Beale Street Could Talk
02. BlacKkKlansman
03. Can You Ever Forgive Me?
04. A Star is Born
05. The Ballad of Buster Scruggs

[NUguy514]

Best Picture
1. Roma
2. The Favourite
3. BlacKkKlansman
.....
4. Black Panther
.....
5. Vice
.....
6. Green Book
7. A Star Is Born
.....
8. Bohemian Rhapsody

I loooooove the first three, loved 4, liked 5 well enough, and didn't like/hated the last three. So help me god, if #6 or #8 wins......

Best Director
1. Alfonso Cuarón
.....
2. Yorgos Lanthimos
3. Spike Lee
4. Paweł Pawlikowski
.....
5. Adam McKay

The first four are fantastic, and even McKay is really good. When Cuarón wins #2 for this, he'll be in my top ten all-time.

Best Actor
1. (Intentionally left blank)
2. Willem Dafoe
3. Christian Bale
4. Viggo Mortensen
5. Bradley Cooper
91. Rami Malek

I hate this fucking category. Honestly, I don't think any of these men deserves to win; I sort of liked Dafoe and Bale, but that's it. When Malek wins (I've accepted it), he will plummet straight to the bottom of my list of Best Actor winners, so well done!

Best Actress
1. Melissa McCarthy
2. Olivia Colman
.....
3. Glenn Close
4. Yalitzia Aparicio
.....
5. Lady Gaga

Aside from Gaga, I think this category is fantastic. I'd rather give the Best Actor Oscar to one of the women on this list and have two winners here instead.

Best Supporting Actor
1. Adam Driver
2. Richard E. Grant
3. Sam Rockwell
.....
4. Mahershala Ali
5. Sam Elliott

I'm not that wild about any of these performances, but I do like the first three quite a bit. I wish Mahershala were in Lead Actor; I could've lived with his winning there, but I guess I'll have to live with it here.

Best Supporting Actress
1. Rachel Weisz
2. Emma Stone
3. Marina de Tavira
4. Regina King
.....
5. Amy Adams

I liked Adams quite a bit, but I absolutely loved the other four. I have King ranked fourth, but I'm rooting for her.

Also! I never ranked last year, probably because I was so pissed off by the acting winners and also refused to see Phantom Thread, and while it really doesn't matter at this point, I still want to rank them because I...'m crazy.

Best Picture
1. The Shape of Water
2. Lady Bird
3. Get Out
.....
4. Call Me by Your Name
.....
5. Dunkirk
6. The Post
7. Darkest Hour
.....
Ninth Circle of Hell
.....
666666666. Three Shitboards Fucking Missouri's Asshole

As I said, I won't see Phantom Thread, but I can't imagine ranking it last given my feelings on that last piece of shit. I loved the first three, have VERY mixed feelings about 4, and didn't like 5-7 at all. I skipped watching the Oscars last year because I could not have handled watching that last film win. Thank all the gods it didn't. Kill it with fucking fire.

Best Director
1. Guillermo del Toro
2. Jordan Peele
3. Greta Gerwig
.....
4. Christopher Nolan
5. Paul Thomas Anderson, probably

I loved the first three and didn't think much of Nolan's work at all.

Best Actor
1. Timothée Chalamet
.....
2. Daniel Kaluuya
.....
3. Gary Oldman
4. Denzel Washington (partially because his movie was so fucking awful)
5. Daniel Day-Lewis (I assume, but maybe he'd be third given how unimpressive I found Oldman and Washington.)

Chalamet was robbed blind by a bunch of fucking morons who don't understand that putting on a bunch of makeup and saying words are things each and every one of them could do and are therefore unworthy of being rewarded with an Oscar for acting. The end.

Best Actress
1. Sally Hawkins
2. Saoirse Ronan
.....
3. Margot Robbie
.....
4. Meryl Streep
5. Frances McDormand (I blame the writing for a lot my issues with this performance, but nope, no thank you.)

I adored the first two and could switch their order tomorrow, really liked #3, and had nothing but antipathy for the last two.

Best Supporting Actor
1. Richard Jenkins
2. Woody Harrelson (the only good thing in his dumpster fire of a movie)
.....
3. Willem Dafoe
.....
4. Sam Rockwell (Fuck. this. Mostly because of the writing again, but still.)

I had/have no interest in Plummer's film, but I can't imagine he'd be higher than third. I thought the first two were great, was really perplexed by the praise for 3, and the last one makes me want to throw up for five hundred years.

Best Supporting Actress
1. Laurie Metcalf
.....
2. Octavia Spencer
.....
3. Allison Janney
4. Mary J. Blige

I actually don't know where Lesley Manville would finish, maybe third or fourth? Really, though, Metcalf was as robbed as Chalamet because the Academy voters don't understand that having a bird on your shoulder and being a one-dimensional abusive monster are actually much, much, MUCH easier than creating a seemingly awful mother who actually has an unbelievable amount of internal complexity is. The acting winners this year fucking sucked, although I can be happy in a general sense that Janney is an Oscar winner.

[Veronica Mars]

Picture
1. The Favourite
2. A Star Is Born
3. Black Panther
4. BlacKkKlansman
5. Roma
6. Vice
7. Green Book
8. Bohemian Rhapsody

Director
1. Pawel Pawlikowski
2. Yorgos Lanthimos
3. Spike Lee
4. Alfonso Cuaron
5. Adam McKay

Actor
1. Bradley Cooper
2. Christian Bale
3. Rami Malek
4. Willem Dafoe
5. Viggo Mortensen

Actress
1. Olivia Colman
2. Melissa McCarthy
3. Lady Gaga
4. Glenn Close
5. Yalitzia Aparicio

Supporting Actor
1. Sam Elliott
2. Richard E. Grant
3. Mahershala Ali
4. Adam Driver
5. Sam Rockwell

Supporting Actress
1. Regina King
2. Rachel Weisz
3. Emma Stone
4. Marina de Tavira
5. Amy Adams

Original Screenplay
1. The Favourite
2. First Reformed
3. Roma
4. Green Book
5. Vice

Adapted Screenplay
1. Can You Ever Forgive Me?
2. If Beale Street Could Talk
3. BlacKkKlansmen
4. A Star Is Born
5. The Ballad of Buster Scruggs

[emmygrammyoscartony]

(02-14-2019 06:45 PM)NUguy514 Wrote:  Best Picture
.....
Ninth Circle of Hell
.....
666666666. Three Shitboards Fucking Missouri's Asshole

Best Actress
5. Frances McDormand (I blame the writing for a lot my issues with this performance, but nope, no thank you.)

I adored the first two and could switch their order tomorrow, really liked #3, and had nothing but antipathy for the last two.

Best Supporting Actor
2. Woody Harrelson (the only good thing in his dumpster fire of a movie)
4. Sam Rockwell (Fuck. this. Mostly because of the writing again, but still)

Best Supporting Actress
1. Laurie Metcalf
3. Allison Janney

I actually don't know where Lesley Manville would finish, maybe third or fourth? Really, though, Metcalf was as robbed as Chalamet because the Academy voters don't understand that having a bird on your shoulder and being a one-dimensional abusive monster are actually much, much, MUCH easier than creating a seemingly awful mother who actually has an unbelievable amount of internal complexity is. The acting winners this year fucking sucked, although I can be happy in a general sense that Janney is an Oscar winner.

*gives standing ovation*

[venom1976]

Picture:
1-Green Book (sorry, I loved it)
2-The Favourite
3-A Star is Born
4-Black Panther
5-Blackkklansman
6-Roma
7-Vice
8-Bohemian Rhapsody

(I would put Can You Ever Forgive Me #3)

Direction:
1-Lanthimos, The Favourite
2-Lee, Blackkklansman
3-Cuaron, Roma
4-McKay, Vice

n/a Pawlikowski, Cold War


Original Screenplay:
1-Green Book
2-The Favourite
3-Roma
4-Vice

n/a First Reformed

Adapted Screenplay:
1-Can You Ever Forgive Me
2-If Beale Street Could Talk
3-Blackkklansman
4-A Star is Born

n/a - The Ballad of Buster Scruggs

(Great category)


Editing:
1-Mavropsaridis, The Favourite
2-Don Vito, Green Book
3-Brown, Blackkklansman
4-Corwin, Vice
5-Ottman, Bohemian Rhapsody


Lead Actor:

1-Mortensen
2-Bale
3-Cooper
4-Malek

n/a -Dafoe


Lead Actress:
1-Colman
2-McCarthy
3-Close
4-Gaga
5-Aparicio


Supporting Actor:
1-Ali
2-Grant
3-Rockwell
4-Driver
5-Elliott

Supporting Actress:
1-Weisz
2-King
3-Stone
4-Adams
5-De Tavira

[emmygrammyoscartony]

Will update when I see "Can You Ever Forgive Me?", "Green Book," "Vice," and rewatch "The Wife" this weekend.

Picture:
1.) A Star Is Born
2.) BlackKklansman
3.) Black Panther
.......
4.) Green Book
5.) Vice
.......
6.) Roma
7.) The Favourite
.......
323.) Bohmenian Crapsody

Direction:
1.) Lee, BlackKklansman
2.) Cuaron, Roma
3.) McKay, Vice
4.) Lanthimos, The Favourite
n/a - Pawlikowski, Cold War

Original Screenplay:
1.) Roma
2.) The Favourite
3.) Vice
4.) Green Book
n/a - First Reformed

Adapted Screenplay:
1.) Blackkklansman
2.) A Star is Born
n/a - The Ballad of Buster Scruggs, Can You Ever Forgive Me?, If Beale Street Could Talk

Lead Actor:
1.) Bradley Cooper
........
2.) Mortensen
3.) Bale
3942.) Rami Malek
n/a - Dafoe

Lead Actress:
1.) Close
2.) Gaga
3.) Aparicio
4.) Colman
n/a - McCarthy

*if anyone is supporting in TF, it is Colman, and she was by far the least impressive of the three.

Supporting Actor:
1.) Elliott
2.) Driver
3.) Ali (he is LEAD)
4.) Rockwell (this nod is bull shit)
n/a - Grant

Supporting Actress:
1.) Stone
2.) Weisz
3.) Adams
4.) de Tavira
n/a - King

[Above the Title]

I finished everything before Sunday.

Best Picture
1. “The Favourite”
2. “Blackkklansman”
3. “A Star is Born”
4. “Roma”
5. “Black Panther”
6. “Vice”
7. “Green Book”
8. “Bohemian Rhapsody”

Best Director
1. Spike Lee
2. Yorgos Lanthimos
3. Pawel Pawlikowski
4. Alfonso Cuaron
5. Adam McKay

Best Actor
1. Bradley Cooper
2. Christian Bale
3. Willem Dafoe
4. Rami Malek
5. Viggo Mortensen

Best Actress
1. Glenn Close
2. Olivia Colman
3. Lady Gaga
4. Melissa McCarthy
5. Yalitza Aparicio
(Honestly a category for the ages)

Best Supporting Actor
1. Richard E. Grant
2. Sam Elliott
3. Adam Driver
4. Mahershala Ali
5. Sam Rockwell

Best Supporting Actress
1. Regina King
2. Rachel Weisz
3. Emma Stone
4. Marina deTavira
5. Amy Adams

Best Original Screenplay
1. “The Favourite”
2. “Roma”
3. “Vice”
4. “First Reformed”
5. “Green Book”

Best Adapted Screenplay
1. “If Beale Street Could Talk”
2. “Blackkklansman”
3. “Can You Ever Forgive Me?”
4. “A Star is Born”
5. “The Ballad of Buster Scruggs”
(Light years better than the other writing category)

Close
Colman
King
Weisz
Gaga
McCarthy
Stone
Cooper
Grant
Aparicio
Bale
Elliott
Driver
Ali
Malek
deTavira
Dafoe
Adams
Mortensen
Rockwell